Client Reviews

Walking in to meet John at our initial appointment, I found myself in a situation I had never been in before. There was a lot of anxiety and even trepidation on my part. However, when I left the office that day, I felt as though I had been heard-and validated-in my feelings about the necessity of pursuing legal action. John listened to my story, responded to questions with patience, and took time to explain anything that needed to be clarified. That day I knew I would be represented well, and with integrity.

In every interaction and communication, I found that Rinehardt Injury Attorneys as a whole carried the same kindness, patience, and care that John had exhibited from that first appointment. At times, walking through the process seemed overwhelming on top of what I was enduring physically. Every person from the firm who contacted me for any reason was so helpful and encouraging. I can’t say enough about this group of people and their commitment to their clients.

There was never a doubt in my mind whether John Rinehardt was looking out for my best interests. Not once. With every conversation, I knew he was trustworthy. He never tried to put words in my mouth. I saw how honorably he conducted himself in the face of the less-than-honorable conduct of others in the mediation process. His excellence and integrity was clear the entire time he represented me. He genuinely expressed many times that he wanted my husband and me to be completely comfortable with any decision that was made. He communicated with transparency and sound advice. It was obvious, John was not “just” our attorney. John Rinehardt became our friend.

Our sincere thanks, John. You have been a true blessing to us. May you be blessed as well!

- Joyce Wolf - 11/19/2018

Mr Rinehardt and his staff were great. They were very timely and anytime I had questions the were just a call away. They treated me like I was their only client I had a great time working with them. I was very satisfied and if I were to ever need them again no doubt about it I will. they absolutely never met a stranger everyone was friendly and I appreciate them all for they’re time and efforts.

- Kardejah

Car Accident / Medical
“Rinehardt Law Firm was amazingly helpful. All my medical bills have been paid and I even received a nice little settlement. I thank all of you that worked on my case. Everyone was very helpful and took the time to explain everything that was happening. I had never filed a lawsuit before and did not know anything about what the process is. They were all very professional and explained everything in detail. Thank you all again.”

- Pamela

Great services
John and his staff were great with making us feel comfortable during the process. They kept us updated on our case progress and were very helpful with all of the paperwork we needed to complete. We are very pleased with the outcome of everything.

- Bethany

Automotive Accident
John was a very understanding and informative. Throughout my entire settlement he was able to answer any questions I presented and was able to find answers with fast response. He made the process less stressful and was able to keep it out of the court room. John is an attorney I will refer without hesitation to anyone in need of one.

- Kate

The John Rinehardt Law Firm is absolutely outstanding! They are not only extremely professional, this team really cares about their clients. They communicated with me about every issue and were always there for me even for the smallest or most trivial reasons. It was their dedication to this client that made all the difference in the world when it came to my recovery, as well as the outcome of my case. I highly recommend John Rinehardt and his team of experts, and would never go anywhere else. The is no replacement for the best!!

- Joe

Positive Outcome
came highly recommended to me for their ethics and professionalism. John and his staff were prompt, thorough and very well organized in representiDuring the winter, I took a fall resulting in a fracture. The law firm of John K. Rinehardt came highly recommended to me for their ethics and professionalism. John and his staff were prompt, thorough and very well organized in representing me. I was treated with compassion and felt very confident that my case was being resolved and therefore was able to focus on recovering. The outcome of the case was positive and very fair. I would not hesitate to recommend Rinehardt Law Firm to others.

- Anonymous Review

I’ve never needed to hire a personal injury lawyer before. But, when I was in a car accident recently and, the other drivers insurance company seemed to be balking at a settlement, I knew I would need help. John Rinehardt was very highly recommended by a friend of mine, so I called him. My husband and I met with him and were treated wonderfully. John and his staff worked very hard for me. I will always recommend him to anyone who needs this kind of help.

- Elizabeth

A+ experience
I worked with Atty Rinehardt in his team for a little over two years. The entire time I was kept informed about my case and treated with deep concern and respect. The entire way through my complicated case I felt that I could trust Atty Rinehardt and his team as they always appeared to have my best interest at heart. Whether I called to ask a question or have a crying break down, the staff was there to listen and support me. I honestly felt like they knew where I was coming from. I would recommend them to anyone. And I do want to give a special thanks to Atty Rinehardt’s assistant GG as she went above and beyond! Thank you to Atty Rinehardt and his team!

- Brandi

Would Recommend to Anyone!
I was a client of John and Hillary recently after being involved in a car accident. Not only did they negotiate a great settlement for me, but every experience I had with them was terrific. The line of communication was continuously open and I always received a timely response to any inquiry I had. Great attorneys but even better people.

- Anonymous

The best by far
John Rinehardt was retained by my father regarding a legal matter that no one else would touch. John listened to my father (unlike others), agreed to take the case and successfully obtained a settlement. John was professional and very involved with the case. My father lived to see the outcome and died in peace. John was always honest and open with us. He did not pull punches and put everything he had into the case. I would recommend him to anyone. He has my complete faith and trust.

- Anonymous

The Best Around
John and his entire staff did an amazing job staying in contact through out the entire time. They’re all well known and come highly recommended. Each and everytime I had a question, it was answered immediately or at the most earliest convenience! I enjoyed the uplifting conversations of reassurance when I ran into an emotional wall of frustration. If you’re looking for a legal team who isn’t afraid of war, John Rinehardt and his team are the way to go! THANKS FOR EVERYTHING AND GOD BLESS!!

- Terrel

My husband and I were involved in motorcycle accident that caused muskeg serious injuries. All of the staff at Rinehardt law firm were absolutely incredible!! John, his wife and the rest of the staff went above and beyond to settle our claim. They were with is every step of the way and I couldn’t be more pleased with the outcome. They were with us through one of the hardest trials we’ve faced and they treated us with nothing but compassion. I would recommend this law firm to everyone!

- Outstanding law firm

I hired the Rinehardt Law Firm to represent me due to an auto accident. Throughout the settlement process John and his staff were very professional, gave clear communication and direction. I was really impressed with how well I was treated. I felt like a VIP. John and his staff are a professional, hard working group of people that cared about me and my outcome. If you are looking for the best, look no further. I highly recommend the Rinehardt Law Firm.

- Terry

Outstanding advocates!
Was extraordinarily impressed with partners’ legal breadth and litigation experience. John, Hillary, and the Rinehardt Law Firm team was there from start to finish, not just advocating for my case, but bringing, as well, an excellent settlement.

- M.R.L.

Car Accident
I used this attorney when I decided to no longer represent myself in a car accident that I was in. Initially I planned on working with the insurance companies myself, but it became overwhelming. I was trying to keep track of all of the bills and payments and could not keep up. From my initial contact with Mr Rinehardt and his staff I felt relief. They took care of everything in a professional and timely manner and I could not be more pleased with the whole experience. Do not hesitate to call

- Private Individual

Car Accident
The entire Staff was absolutely wonderful. I was treated with kindness and respect. All of my questions were answered promptly and care. Being pregnant after the car accident they really cared about me and the well being of my family. Throughout the process I have to say they all were GREAT! Thank you so much for helping me and my family!

- Private Individual

The outstanding service and communication of the Rinehardt practice is beyond excellent. We were treated with respect, always knew what the status of our case was, appointments were made with our work schedules in mind and the outcome of our case was beyond what we expected. A professional, yet real people, practice. Our family would highly recommend this practice for any type of legal need

- Private Individual

Motorcycle Accident
I am so glad we chose Rinehardt law firm to represent us. We were in a very bad motorcycle accident and the went above and beyond settling our case for us. We were treated like family and were kept involved every step of the way. Thank you all who were involved in one way or other working our case! You all did an incredible job!

- Private Individual

John and the women in the office were great. Communicated very well. Always kept us up to date on anything going on. Called every time something new happened. Anything from us need was explained in detail and was very easy to work through. Couldn’t tell you how much it means to my family and I. The firm was great to work with. Wouldn’t change a thing. Can’t thank them enough.

- Private Individual

Personal Injury
In late 2011 I suffered an injury that change my life forever. Mistakes made by others had left me afraid I may not ever recover from injuries. Complications to my health added to what was already a bleak situation. By the grace of God the Rinehardt Law firm was there every step of the way. John and his team of professionals worked tirelessly to make sure everything was taken care of. They were always there for me no matter how small the issue. I personally highly recommend the Rinehardts!

- Private Individual

Personal Injury
During the winter I took a fall resulting in a fracture. The law firm of John K. Rinehardt came highly recommended to me for their ethics and professionalism. John and his staff were prompt, thorough and very well organized in representing me. I was treated with compassion and felt very confident that my situation was being resolved and therefore was able to focus on my recovery. The outcome of the case was positive and very fair. I would not hesitate to recommend Rinehardt Law Firm to others.

- Private Individual

Automotive Accident
I was in an automotive accident and hospitalized for a month. John was able to get a settlement in a short period of time and without having to take the case to court. Very understanding and able to explain every aspect of the legal process so I knew all processes and stages. I will highly recommend him to anyone who is looking for an attorney

- Private Individual

My attorney John Rinehardt and his staff were very informative and very helpful in obtaining my settlement. They were very patient with all my questions. They fulfilled everything that they said they would.
I would very much recommend his services and would use them in the future if the need would arise

- Rochelle Frame

Car Accident
My wife was in a car wreck that injured her knee. The other driver was at fault, his insurance company was more than kind to take care of the bills until my wife needed surgery from her injury. Well that’s where Mr. Rinehardt enters the scene, we just wanted my wife’s bills covered. I was thinking this small town attorney, what can he really do? My wife wanted to stay close because she didn’t to travel to a big city. I have to say, I had to eat my words. Mr. Rinehardt and his entire staff were OUTSTANDING, made us feel like family, even myself and I wasn’t his client, they kept us well informed and told us to be patient. Not only did he get the medical covered, he got my wife a nice little settlement. We are not ones to file lawsuits, the first in either of our lives and hopefully the last but if the need ever comes up, Mr. Rinehardt and his law firm will be our choice. Thanks again John and thank you to all the Rinehardt Law Firm staff.

- Dennis Gast

From the first phone call through the end, everyone I talked to was genuinely interested in what I had to say and what brought me into their office. They treat you like family. I would call them again in a heartbeat. Have patience and let them do what they do best.

- Stacy Oswalt

The Rinehardt law firm is top notch. My case was not the typical case they handle but they took care of the matter and due to special circumstances waived their usual fee as well! What law firm does that?!? John, Stephanie and the entire staff are very courteous and professional.

- Darrell

Auto Accident
After an automotive accident and dealing with a very difficult insurance company /agent to settle my claim, I sought the help of Rinehardt Law Firm. Attorney John and his staff- Gigi, Stephanie and Patty- were wonderful throughout the process. If it weren’t for their diligence and hard work, I would still be fighting the insurance company. I highly recommend Rinehardt Law Firm to anyone seeking help with a claim.

- Beth L

I was in a accident that lead me to The Rinehardt Law Firm. John and his team are the definition of professional integrity. I can’t say enough on how much John and his staff helped me. John and his team gave me my faith back that their are good people out there to help you in your time of need. I highly recommend The Rinehardt Law Firm to help you. They are the Best!

- Sara Runals

I can not say enough about John and his staff. The compassion and concern that was shown from them is beyond description. John is by far one of the most trustworthy professionals I have ever met and working with him was made very easy because of it. We were always kept up to date on our case and all questions were answered quickly and professionally. He went above and beyond for us and for that we are forever grateful. I highly recommend John and his staff for any problem that needs a great Attorney and wonderful staff. The Steele family.

- Pam Steele

The Rinehardt law firm has to be the most professional and caring people in my time of need. My overall experience from the first phone conversation to the last hand shake has been amazing. The staff are the most caring and helpful people from simple questions to even just friendly phone call to checking up on you to see how your doing. Attorney John Rinehardt has been amazing, one of my favorite things besides his true sincerity is that he treats you like a person regardless of education or financial status. He always managed to follow up on things from previous conversations from a week ago to months prior. I would personally recommend this firm to anyone in need. It has surpassed my expectations. Thank you and your staff from the bottom of my heart. You and your staff are the best

- Ross Wind

John, Stephanie, Melodie and the rest of the staff at The Rinehart Law Offices are really terrific. My husband was hit by a car and we have spent quite a bit of time in and out of hospitals, nursing homes and more hospitals. They are so kind, caring and professional. When ever I hit a “bump in the road” and had questions they always worked hard to help me find answers and solve the problems.
There is no need to go anywhere else but here for help from honest, upstanding attorneys.
A heartfelt thank you to you all for all your help! We will definitely refer your Firm to everyone we know and will be back if we are ever in need again!
God bless you all!

- Melody R.

John Rinehardt began assisting me over a year ago in my minor son’s father’s wrongful death settlement. I was not the fiduciary or executor of the estate and thought I had little legal ground to stand on. When my son (4 years old) was offered only 10% of the settlement and I was being bullied by the law firm representing the estate I called and e-mailed John several times for advice. He walked me through every single step of the process. I refused to sign off on anything on my son’s behalf and had the opportunity to put the distribution decision in front of a probate Judge. I would not have had the confidence or know how to do any of this on my own. John was kind and patient and really quite literally treated my son and I like family. I am happy to report that my son was awarded a fair share and I was even granted back child. I couldn’t have hoped for a better outcome. If you are looking for an attorney that will truly have your best interest at heart and teach you a few things along the way I HIGHLY recommend Rinehardt Law Firm.

- Meagan W.

After an auto accident it became apparent that I was going to require assistance. Having never previously required any legal representation – I started seeking referrals from friends and family. I received John’s name through a trusted friend (who just also happened to be an attorney). I contacted John and set up a consultation. John was very informative and generous with his time walking me through the entire process and explaining the different directions that my case could go. Unfortunately (or fortunately) my case ended up going to trial. John and Hilliary were complete professionals, talk about a dynamic duo. John’s experience in the courtroom was clearly evident from the opening argument all the way through to the closing. John was able to clearly lay out our case and it was clear that the jury was able to relate and follow along. John’s experience in the courtroom along with Hilliary’s dedicated work behind the scenes was superb. The care that they showed both myself and my wife – we felt like they were fighting for one of their own family members. I truly appreciate their hard work and dedication and would recommend them to anyone that finds themselves needing a legal expert. Thank you again to you both –

- Kyle N.

“After an auto accident it became apparent that I was going to require assistance. Having never previously required any legal representation – I started seeking referrals from friends and family. I received John’s name through a trusted friend (who just also happened to be an attorney). I contacted John and set up a consultation. John was very informative and generous with his time walking me through the entire process and explaining the different directions that my case could go.

- K.N.

“I was in a car accident in 2004 that left me in a wheelchair for two years. I had a total of eight surgeries. John was so sympathetic and he wanted to do the best possible job for me that he could. I was impressed by how quickly he took action. The staff was so helpful and always took the time to answer my many questions or just listen when I was having a rough time. John was always prepared and would take the time to explain things to me. The Rinehardt Law Firm worked so very hard to settle my case in a timely manner, but left no stone unturned. I have and always will recommend the Rinehardt Law Firm because they will always have your best interest at heart. They are honest, up-front, and never leave you feeling confused about what is going on in your case.”

- S.S

“We wanted to thank everyone for all of their help over the last couple years. Everything was always handled very professionally. In addition, we were always treated with concern and kindness. Our questions were always answered, no matter how often we had to ask. We really appreciate everything and would gladly recommend your office to anyone.”

- D.S.

“I am so Blessed that I found the Rinehardt law Firm and that they took my case. They are an amazing team to have on your side when you’re in need of a Lawyer. I had never had to have a lawyer represent me before this, and I was so scared to have to go through this process of having to sue a Big Corporation for what had happened to me. But the Rinehardt Law Firm was not. They worked so hard on my case and they believed in me and my case. This was a slip and fall case in Ohio so they had their work cut out for them to prove my case. I seen John and Hillary fighting for me as if I was their own daughter. I seen them in action as we prepared for a jury trial the Big corporation thought they could outsmart the Rinehardt Lawyers with false information and tried to lie about certain things that they did not want to come out, But the Rinehardt law firm exposed the truth and it all came out in the end in front of a judge and a jury because John and Hillary and their team worked, and worked they found the truth. The Rinehardt Law firm are a Power House Team. They WILL bring you JUSTICE and they will treat you as if you are family. Not only did they win my case they went over and beyond to give justice for me and my family I feel that I have gained new friends that will always have my back in a time of need Thank You for all of your hard work and dedication that you have given me during one of the most detrimental times in my life. These are the Lawyers you want on your side. THE RINEHARDT LAW FIRM are my HEROES.”

- T.T

“I just wanted to take a moment to thank all of you for our advice and support during the entire lawsuit process. All of your hard work has given me the chance to spend the next few months with a bald, toothless, but still very good looking little man. (her new baby!)”

- M.J.

“John and his paralegal team at the office worked very hard on my case and I am very proud of them!! This will be the third time that I have used Rinehardt Law Firm and they never let me down even though i didn’t think things were going to work out at the end, they definitely proved me wrong on that decision. John and his team at the office worked hard throughout the last three cases they represented me on and I cannot say enough about there firm!!..I strongly agree that John is the best and definitely would use him in the future!!…You cannot go wrong with John!!!”

- S.H.

Columbus Office

Rinehardt Injury Attorneys
8351 N. High St, Ste 251,
Columbus, OH 43235
Phone Number: (614) 686-2020
Get Directions

Ready to get Started?

We’re here to help you and your family get back on track after an accident. Reach out to us today for a free case evaluation.

Million Dollar Advocates Form Logo
National Board of Trial Advocacy Badge
Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Form Logo
Injury Board Logo
American Association for Justice logo
Martin-Hubbell AV-Preeminent logo
SuperLawyers Clevland top 50 logo
SuperLawyers John K. Rinehardt 5 years
SuperLawyers Clevland top 100 logo
The National Trial Lawyers